The Rise of Nationalism: How It Impacts Food Choices and the Importance of Storytelling

A resurgence of nationalism is impacting various aspects of our lives, including our food choices. If you're located on the north side of the Canada-US border, you may have noticed a lot of grocery shoppers wearing their reading glasses to see the fine print and country of origin. Consumers are increasingly interested in knowing where their food comes from and are actively seeking out locally sourced options in a desire to support local farmers and the national economy. While these actions can boost local economies and preserve cultural identity, they can also lead to protectionist measures that limit consumer choice and hinder international trade.

Why do farmers' markets continue to increase in popularity, even in an increasingly digital age? Consumers crave authentic, local food experiences and a connection to the source of their food. By understanding human emotions and leveraging the power of storytelling, food businesses can connect with consumers on a deeper level, build trust, and create lasting brand loyalty.

The Importance of Storytelling in Marketing

We are fundamentally emotional beings. While we often pride ourselves on our rationality, our emotions drive our decisions, shape our perceptions, and influence our actions more than we care to acknowledge. That’s particularly true when it comes to food, as it leverages all of our senses and is deeply intertwined with our memories, cultural identity, and sense of belonging. By sharing the provenance, history, and origin of their products, companies can tap into consumers' emotional connection with food and create a sense of authenticity.

Storytelling, in its essence, is about connecting with these emotions. It's a practice as old as humanity itself. Since the time our ancestors gathered around the fire, stories have served as a powerful tool for transmitting knowledge, sharing experiences, and forging social bonds. These narratives weren't just dry recitations of facts and figures; they were infused with emotion, drama, and relatable characters, making them memorable and impactful.

Neurologically, stories engage multiple parts of our brain. They activate the areas responsible for language processing, but also those involved in experiencing emotions, sensory perception, and memory. When we hear a compelling story, we don't just passively listen; we actively participate, creating a mental image and experiencing the emotions of the characters. This immersive experience makes stories far more persuasive and memorable than simply presenting information. We are hardwired for stories, and by telling the right ones, we can truly capture the hearts (and stomachs) of our audience.

By tapping into these emotional touchpoints, food businesses can create powerful narratives that differentiate their products and build lasting relationships with consumers. These stories can be conveyed through various channels, including:

  • Product Packaging: A short, compelling story printed on the label can transform a simple product into a cherished item. QR codes allow consumers to explore the product further and even see it being grown, raised, or harvested in real-time.

  • Website and Social Media: Sharing videos and blog posts that tell the story of the brand, its founders, or its products can engage consumers and build a loyal following.

  • Marketing Campaigns: Advertising campaigns that focus on storytelling can create an emotional connection with consumers and drive sales.

Find the Romance in Your Geography

Food with a story tastes better, or at least it feels like it does. That emotional connection, that sense of knowing the origin and the values behind a product, enhances the entire experience. If you’ve ever read the outer packaging of a bottle of Scotch or Irish whiskey, you know what I’m talking about. Here are some examples of brands and food regions that excel at this, regardless of tariffs:

  • Italy (Tuscany, Emilia-Romagna): Italian cuisine is steeped in history and tradition, and producers in these regions are masters of telling stories about their food. From the ancient vineyards of Tuscany to the Parmigiano-Reggiano producers of Emilia-Romagna, the narratives emphasize the quality of local ingredients, the time-honoured techniques passed down through generations, and the cultural significance of food. Every ingredient in every dish has a story.

  • France (Champagne, Burgundy): Similar to Italy, French food regions are renowned for their storytelling. Champagne producers emphasize the unique terroir, the meticulous process, and the history of the region. Burgundy winemakers focus on the specific vineyards and their microclimates, the grape varietals, and the generations of families who have cultivated the land.

  • Mexico (Oaxaca, Chiapas): Mexican cuisine is rich in indigenous traditions and cultural heritage. Regions like Oaxaca and Chiapas tell stories about the origins of ingredients like corn and chocolate, the traditional methods of cooking, and the cultural significance of food in their communities.

Facts Are Informative; Stories Are Emotional

Remember, it's not just about what you sell; it's about the story you tell. You have to look beyond the data and facts and get to what resonates, the reason to believe. Here are three pointers to start you thinking about your unique story.


1. Everyone has a story to tell

  • Compelling stories don't need to be extraordinary. The most relatable and engaging stories often come from everyday experiences, and sometimes you’re too close to your own business to know them when you see them. Marketers can learn to find the extraordinary in the ordinary aspects of their brand or product and share those authentic moments with their audience.

2. Details matter

  • Sensory Language: Sensory details bring brand stories to life, making them more engaging and memorable. Paint a picture with words of what makes you special.

3. Embrace vulnerability

  • Authenticity: Marketers can learn to be more authentic and transparent in their storytelling, connecting with consumers on a deeper level. Consumers just want to know the truth!

By sharing the provenance, history, and origin of their products, brands, be they countries or companies, can create a sense of authenticity and differentiate themselves in a competitive market. As a food agency expert, I believe that storytelling will continue to shape consumer choices and drive the success of food businesses in the years to come.

Let Nourish Help You Find Your Story

So, how do you decide what to tell your customers, existing and prospective, to engage them with your brand to turn them into loyal buyers? Here’s one way: join us in person or virtually for a free storytelling session. Spend two hours talking about your favourite subject—yourself! We’ll help you find what makes you unique and provide insights on how to tell your story so it resonates with consumers. Reach out to me today and let’s have a chat! You’re never too old for storytime.


Nourish-Food-Marketing-2025-Trend-Report-Mock-Up-Cover-EN

Download Our FREE 2025 Trend Report

Download

We’d love to hear from you

Think we can help? Give us a little background and we’ll have the right person get back to you quickly.